FOX GETS IT RIGHT ON
SUPER NIGHT
Fox's pregame a Super show of promotion
Take the Game, Leave the ‘Idol’
WHNT sportscaster's leaving again
ESPN to Offer Sports Events on the Web Free to Some
MEDIA WATCH: Local sports talk radio undergoes big changes
Joe Buck, Troy Aikman make right calls
Buck, Aikman get Super credit
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
FOX GETS IT RIGHT ON SUPER NIGHT
New
York Post
February 4, 2008 -- THE Giants won the what?
Pats owner Bob Kraft, in the CBS booth with Jim Nantz
during the PGA's FBR/Phoenix Open, Saturday, said jokingly,
"We promised Fox we'd keep it close for a half."
But the Pats did better than that; they kept it close
for both halves of Super Bowl XLII, losing 17-14 to
the Giants and blowing their chance for a perfect season.
Fox had a good night in that we didn't miss anything
we had to see. That super slo-mo replay of that unreal
David Tyree catch with one minute left showed exactly
how spectacular it was. No network had a better response
to a big play, all season.
And Fox didn't over-play any angle. And Joe Buck, who
is always better when he doesn't force it, didn't force
it.
Still, there were some odd moments.
The oddest, by far, came with 2:40 left in the first
quarter, Giants up, 3-0. Troy Aikman said that during
a visit with Tom Brady, during the week, he was left
with the impression that Brady's ankle is injured worse
than Brady was letting on. Really? But isn't that something
Aikman might have told us, say, at the very top?
And rather than telling us that Randy Moss is being
shut out, couldn't Fox, in an isolated clip package,
have shown us how? Maybe during the halftime on-site
studio show? We got our first peek on tape with six
seconds left in the third. Yet, when a player showboats,
Fox shows it at least twice.
And isn't it worth asking why, as long as they were
unstoppable, the Pats wouldn't go with Brady to Wes
Welker on just about every play?
Some more odds and ends: Good catch, by Fox, showing
Jeremy Shockey in a luxury box (as opposed to the Giants'
sideline) looking more like a beach bum than a teammate.
. . . Wouldn't it be easier if Fox told us which of
its shows are not viewer discretion advised?
The first quarter ran 27 minutes. The third quarter
ran 35 minutes. Halftime ran 32 minutes. . . . And football
telecasts without fantasy league stats all over the
screen sure look a lot more like football games, don't
they?
Fox, yesterday, presented a nine-hour, 30-minute Super
Bowl pre-game show, starting with a Suped-up "Fox
News Sunday" at 9 a.m., apparently for those who
previously had no idea what was going on much, much
later. In so doing, Fox created for itself an all-day
invite to change the channel, to watch anything else.
Only ESPN's Monday Night Football pregame come-ons,
which begin Tuesday mornings, are longer.
Fox's Super Bowl excesses were such that those who actually
paid attention to one of them were encouraged to miss
much of the first half. Really.
Saturday, Fox-5 posted a countdown-to-kickoff clock,
one that was an hour off. Thus, at 6:05 p.m., Fox's
clock told us that kickoff was, "1 day, 1 hour
and 12 minutes" away. That would have made it a
7:17 kickoff when it was scheduled for 6:17. (Kickoff
actually came at 6:30.)
*
The biggest weasel of Super Bowl Week was Chris Russo.
Despite having trashed Pedro Martinez, two years ago,
for dogging it - days later,
Martinez underwent surgery - Russo, a slow-learner,
was at it again, fully implying that LaDainian Tomlinson
was gutless, two weeks ago, when he left the AFC Championship
with an injury.
Though Tomlinson has no history of dogging it, and Russo
never tried to explain what would motivate Tomlinson
to sit out a championship game when he could have played,
Russo did have a chance to repeat his "Show some
guts!" criticisms of Tomlinson when Tomlinson was
Russo's and Mike Francesa's guest, Wednesday, from Arizona.
Fat chance. With Tomlinson there, Russo spoke in broad
terms of how "people like me" were confused;
they couldn't understand why
Tomlinson didn't return to the game.
Russo certainly didn't repeat his "Show some guts!"
spew about Tomlinson to Tomlinson. He could have even
replayed, for Tomlinson, either of his NBC "Mad
Dog Minute" attacks on Tomlinson for gutlessness.
He didn't sound the least bit confused about Tomlinson
during those spews.
In another Francesa/Russo consistency, Russo's implications
that Tomlinson is gutless were made only before and
after Tomlinson's appearance with them. So who, in the
end, offered the only hard evidence of being gutless?
--------------------------------------------
Fox's
pregame a Super show of promotion
By Michael Hiestand, USA
TODAY
Fox's Howie Long, as the network's Super Bowl pregame
coverage began at noon ET Sunday, said for players and
coaches awaiting the kickoff "the minutes seem
like hours; the hours seem like weeks."
That would also be true for viewers who watched all
the pregame coverage. But Super Bowl pregame shows,
like pregame chips 'n' dip, are meant for hours of off-and-on
grazing.
And it lets a network hype its parent company's other
properties on a show that draws more eyeballs —
even though pregame shows aren't really about football
— than nearly everything in TV sports outside
of the NFL.
News Corp.'s Fox took full advantage. It used Ryan Seacrest,
host of its American Idol, in what was billed as the
first made-for-TV Super Bowl red-carpet walk —
and probably not the last. Fox's Terry Bradshaw probably
spoke for many viewers: "Seacrest, the only time
I thought I'd see you at the Super Bowl would be as
a cheerleader."
Said Fox NFL pregame comedian Frank Caliendo: "Boy,
nothing says 'NFL-tough' like Ryan Seacrest. I guess
Richard Simmons was booked."
Or maybe it's just that Simmons isn't on some Fox show.
Caliendo also appeared with psychologist Dr. Phil. Seacrest,
on the carpet, talked to actors from the (Fox) TV series
House and upcoming (Fox) movie Jumper and viewers saw
footage from a regular person on (Fox-owned) myspace.com.
Idol judge Paula Abdul performed a song on Idol judge
Randy Jackson's new album, prompting Jackson to say,
"Paula Abdul is hot!"
Otherwise, Seacrest didn't create many memorable moments
on the carpet — "Is this your first red carpet?"
he asked NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell — as he
called for game predictions from celebs who didn't have
much to say. After asking John Krasinski of The Office
on (believe it or not) NBC for his game pick, the actor
noted he was wearing a Patriots cap. Seacrest responded
Krasinski was too tall for him to notice.
Off-carpet, Fox had plenty of the usual pregame staples
such as player up-close-and-personals — who knew
New York Giants wide receiver Plaxico Burress collects
socks? — and musical acts such as Willie Nelson
and Sara Evans singing Mama, Don't Let Your Babies Grow
Up to Be Cowboys. But this being the Super Bowl pregame,
not just any venue, they changed the line at least once
to "Mamas, don't raise your cowboys to be babies."
On the NFL Network, singer Alicia Keys said her pregame
performance on Fox would be "eight minutes of thunder
and heaven" — but sounded like just a pop
singer.
There were glimpses of the week-long Super Bowl party
scene. After Seacrest introduced Fox NFL weather reporter
Jillian Reynolds as "the first lady of Fox Sports,"
she offered taped party patter. At a Victoria's Secret
shindig, underwear model Karolina Kurkova volunteered
what she finds interesting about football: "They
get down and dirty. It's fun to watch."
But if Fox's pregame show, like all pregame shows, was
about as nutritious as Super Bowl home snacking, Fox
deserves a huge gold star for its closing element: A
reading, with roles for various NFL-related people,
of the Declaration of Independence. Fox also did that
in the pregame for the first post-9/11 Super Bowl. Sunday,
Fox was tasteful — especially in including Marie
Tillman, the widow of NFL star Pat
Tillman — and largely redeemed itself after its
frothiness.
Once kickoff came, announcers Joe Buck and Troy Aikman
sounded like they were calling their usual Sunday afternoon
lead Fox game — which was good. They largely avoided
breathless hype — such as Long saying the undefeated
Patriots were playing "for forever" —
and offered early insights, such as noting Tom Brady
didn't seem comfortable throwing from the get-go. Given
the great on-field action, Fox largely let the game
speak for itself. Overall, the announcers and Fox's
camera shots did what they needed to do with the great
on-field action; Fox didn't blow it.
Bradshaw, who'd called Giants coach Tom Coughlin a "jerk"
and "stupid" during the 2004 season, said
after the game he was "shocked" by the upset
which, among Fox pregame analysts, had been predicted
only by Caliendo — allowing the comedian to finish
first in the cast's season-long prediction rankings.
But the really big winner Sunday had to be the marketer
whose ads Sunday already featured Eli and Peyton Manning
— Oreo's Double Stuf Racing League — where
the last two Super Bowl MVPs are shown competing in
a "licking" contest.
-----------------------------------------------------
Take the Game, Leave the ‘Idol’
By RICHARD SANDOMIR, New
York Times
By the time Eli Manning kneeled down on the final play
of the Giants’ 17-14 Super Bowl win Sunday night,
the memory of Ryan Seacrest in the pregame show was
nearly gone. His most welcome words: “Seacrest
out,” or something like that, as the “American
Idol” host bid adieu.
No network can get a multihour pregame show right, and
Fox didn’t, thanks to turning it into an “American
Idol” promotion with Seacrest as a co-host at
the red carpet and Paula Abdul in a taped performance.
And while I like reading the Declaration of Independence
on days other than the Fourth of July, let me note that
Fox’s summer stock re-enactment of its signing
was better with the songs of “1776.” But
Fox did the game very well. Joe Buck and Troy Aikman
have never been better in doing what they should do.
Buck set up the action, offered some storytelling and
made sharp calls.
You want your play-by-play announcer to be alert enough
to note quickly that Manning’s interception by
Ellis Hobbs was his first since he threw one to Hobbs
in the Giants’ 38-35 loss to the Patriots in Week
17.
Aikman provided intelligent commentary that focused
on several distinct areas, including the Giants’
blitzing and how the defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo
did not mind leaving Randy Moss in one-on-one coverage,
the rhythm that Patriots quarterback Tom Brady almost
never found; pass-pattern dissection, and how Patriots
receiver Wes Welker was almost magically able to find
the soft spots in the Giants’ secondary.
•
Analysts often get lucky when something happens soon
after they predict it. With the Patriots ahead, 14-10,
with 2 minutes 42 seconds left, Aikman said, “When
you look at what Eli has done in these situations, I
think he really tends to shine in the no-huddle.”
With 45 seconds left, and the Giants facing a third-and-11
at the New England 25, Aikman suggested that Manning
throw a screen pass to Brandon Jacobs. The toss to Steve
Smith looked like close kin to a screen, and went for
12 yards.
Manning’s career-defining play — a Fran
Tarkenton-like escape from what appeared to be a sack,
with 1:15 left, that ended with David Tyree’s
astonishing catch might have begged the question of
whether Manning was “in the grasp.” But
after watching the replay several times after the game,
no defender had a firm hold on him.
I’ve read e-mail messages and blog comments that
have painted Buck as a pale clone of his father, Jack;
for somehow being sanctimonious; and for offering little
insight. I’ve never understood them beyond viewers’
feeling that Buck is overexposed through his baseball
and football work; through his commercials (not all
of them well-chosen vehicles); and because of residual
good will for the man he replaced at Fox, Pat Summerall.
But no negative qualities were in evidence Sunday night.
The star of the game was not either announcer, however,
but the FoxScope, the super-slow-motion technology that
elevated the use of replay beyond the necessary tool
it has been for several decades. It illuminated how
Brady’s sore ankle planted before passing, a sideline
pass to Amani Toomer, the fumble by Ahmad Bradshaw,
a fumble forced from Brady’s hand by Justin Tuck,
and how Tyree held the ball against his helmet on his
miraculous catch.
But a standard tool, the 50-yard-line camera that captures
the bulk of the live action, seemed to be mounted noticeably
too high. A Fox spokesman said it was in its usual perch
at University of Phoenix Stadium, but it still seemed
too far away.
Fox showed the right storytelling touch as the game
crescendoed with the Giants ahead for good. With 10
seconds left and the Patriots facing fourth down and
the loss of their unbeaten season, Fox rolled in a taped
package about the undefeated 1972 Miami Dolphins, gleeful
once again, and maybe for 35 more years. Fox then cut
to Brady conferring with Coach Bill Belichick, grumpier
throughout the fourth quarter than Barry Switzer, one
of Fox’ grumpy old men, ever was.
•
But Giants Coach Tom Coughlin looked Lucky Charms-happy.
During one of the pregame features, he said something
fascinating: that he understood interpersonal relationships
even when his face seemed as if it would explode with
anger, but that this season he decided to apply that
knowledge of human behavior to the humans on his team.
One final thought, regarding the presence of Seacrest
and his “American Idol” crew. Seacrest is
bland, much like Carson Daly, who did nothing for a
CBS pregame show several years ago. Seacrest offered
little on a program filled with greater personalities,
like Terry
Bradshaw, Jimmy Johnson and Howie Long, and football
features that in nearly every instance were shorter
than they should have been.
The so-called merger of celebrity and sports is a fantasy
of networks like Fox and ESPN (witness the ESPYs show);
yes, sports is entertainment, but on Super Bowl Sunday,
football and some good musical performances can carry
the pregame festivities.
------------------------------------------------
WHNT sportscaster's leaving again
The
Huntsville Times
WHNT-TV sportscaster John Pearson, who has been at Channel
19 more than seven years during two different tenures
at the station, will be leaving at the end of the month,
WHNT general manager/president Stan Pylant confirmed.
A native of Geneseo, Ill., Pearson first came to WHNT
in 1994, and after four years covering sports, moved
to Milwaukee to cover sports there. He returned to WHNT
in 2005.
"As for sports coverage, we want to take advantage
of every platform (Web, wireless, digital) available
to us for local and regional sports and feel that it's
time to set a different course," Pylant said in
an e-mail. "John will be with us through February.
We are appreciative for what John's brought to the station
and wish him only the best."
Pearson said he's enjoyed his return to Huntsville and
may stay around the area because his wife, Amy, is happy
with her job.
"It's been great," Pearson said. "I moved
back here with the reason to build something and because
we were treated so well the first time around. I was
brought in to do things and I did things, but apparently
it wasn't for the long term."
WAFF-TV
Channel 48, the NBC affiliate, continued its four-year
domination of this television market by winning one
of the most important Nielsen ratings period of the
year - November.
WAFF
captured the top ratings in the 5, 6 and 10 p.m. newscasts.
WHNT-TV Channel 19, the CBS affiliate, was second and
WAAY-TV Channel 31, the ABC affiliate that's revamped
its nightly news with a new anchor team, remained a
distant third.
WAFF
has been No. 1 in the Nielsen television ratings for
local newscasts 15 of the last 16 ratings periods since
2003. Ratings are determined by viewer diaries and measured
two ways in this area - the four-county Metro area:
Madison, Morgan, Limestone and Lawrence - and the 11-county
Designated Marketing Area: Lauderdale, Colbert, Franklin,
Lawrence, Madison, Limestone, Marshall, Morgan, Jackson,
DeKalb and Lincoln.
WAAY
started revamping its newscasts last July when it hired
anchor Michael Scott for the nightly shows and longtime
award-winning anchor Erin Dacy eventually went to the
morning newscasts. In September, Karen Adams joined
Scott on the anchor desk for the 5, 6 and 10 p.m. shows.
The
next Nielsen ratings period is at the end of this month,
and it should be interesting to see how a new addition
to the market is doing. Last month, WZDX-TV Fox 54 started
doing 9 o'clock newscasts featuring an anchor desk and
production team out of Davenport, Iowa, with local reporting
by Ken Conley and Jamiese Price.
--------------------------------------
ESPN
to Offer Sports Events on the Web Free to Some
New
York Times
ESPN,
the dominant channel for sports programming, will announce
this week that Web users on college campuses and military
bases — anyone in the .edu or .mil domain —
will be able to access live programming on its Web site,
ESPN360, without charge.
Opening ESPN360’s doors to college students and
members of the military will more than double its base
of possible users, potentially driving traffic to a
site that has recorded only 500,000 viewing hours since
it started focusing on live sporting events last September.
Cable companies pay nearly $3 a subscriber to broadcast
ESPN on television. But its Web site, which provides
live coverage of more than 2,500 sporting events a year,
is accessible only to the 20 million subscribers to
Internet service providers that have reached agreements
with ESPN.
In adopting a subscriber fee format, the company has
tried to apply the closed model of cable television
to the widely accessible avenues of the Internet.
“The high-speed data marketplace is evolving much
like the multichannel TV marketplace did 20 to 30 years
ago,” said David Preschlack, the executive vice
president for affiliate sales and marketing for Disney
and ESPN Media Networks.
“Future growth for I.S.P.’s will not be
based on speed and price of service, as it largely has
been up to now, but rather on the value of the content
they offer.”
ESPN, which is 80 percent owned by the Walt Disney Company
and 20 percent by Hearst Corporation, has frustrated
some fans by putting an electronic wall around some
sporting events. Users cannot subscribe to the service
separately; they receive it through their Internet service
provider or not at all.
AT&T, Verizon, RCN and Charter are among those that
offer it. On Friday ESPN signed an agreement with Insight,
a Midwestern cable operator, which will make the platform
available to 700,000 subscribers next week.
But several major cable operators, Comcast and Time
Warner Cable among them, have not signed on.
The notion of paying a subscriber fee for content is
relatively new to the mainstream Internet, and fairly
uncomfortable.
Some telephone and cable companies have considered charging
content providers for priority access, raising concerns
about so-called network neutrality, a tenet that rejects
discrimination in the transmission of online information.
ESPN is practicing the reverse, charging the carriers
to give users access to a Web site.
Eric Rabe, a vice president for communications for Verizon,
said ESPN360 could attract users.
“You can’t underestimate the value of live,
streaming sports in attracting customers who are extremely
loyal and who will also want television and mobile phone
services from Verizon,” he said.
Disney operates a similar site, called Disney Connection,
with children’s television shows and games.
The advertising-free service is available through Comcast,
Mediacom, Verizon and other high-speed Internet services.
The Disney-ABC television group also offers Soapnetic,
a broadband video site for soap opera fans, through
several Internet providers.
John Zehr, the network’s senior vice president
for digital media production, said the ESPN360 platform
allowed the broadcaster to expand beyond its six cable
channels.
In September, ESPN360 moved from mostly taped to mostly
live programming. There is no shortage of programming;
“24 hours a day, there is some sporting event
being played around the globe,” Mr. Zehr said.
Last month, the service showed more than 450 hours of
Australian Open tennis as well as 225 college basketball
games, cricket matches, international soccer matches
and the Winter X Games. Mr. Zehr said the Australian
Open coverage was especially popular.
“While our linear network can only bring you one
court at a time, you can be watching six different courts
within the application,” he said.
“I’m not necessarily the biggest tennis
fan in the world, but it’s turning me into one
because I’ve been able to follow all the matches.”
----------------------------------------
MEDIA
WATCH: Local sports talk radio undergoes big changes
By
Mike Tankersley, Montgomery
Advertiser
Wow. What a difference a week makes in local sports
talk radio. In a span of two days last week, there were
two significant developments, and both affected Prattville-based
WIQR-AM 1410.
First, Max Howell's Max'd Out closed operations after
Monday's show. This move wasn't unexpected, but the
original plan called for Howell's show to finish out
the week leading up to Super Bowl weekend. Regardless,
Howell's Florida Panhandle-based show is gone locally,
but there is more to the story.
"We've packed up and we're hitting the road,"
Howell said by phone Friday night. "We're on our
way to Jackson, Miss."
Howell's show, with the name intact, will re-emerge
on Feb. 18 in Jackson on the ESPN affiliate there, WPBQ-AM
1240. It'll air from 3-6 p.m.
His Florida-based show had been airing from 9 a.m.-noon.
"Believe it or not, that station (WPBQ) has never
had a drive-time sports show," Howell said. "They're
promising a lot of support and promotion for the show,
and let's face it. When you're talking about sports
talk shows, you've got to go with ESPN.
"I'm real excited about it."
Howell's show will be available in a couple of Alabama
markets, but not here. WIQR owner Greg Meadows has already
replaced Max'd Out with The Dan Patrick Show. Because
this latest version of the Patrick show ends at 11 a.m.,
Meadows has reinstated the first hour of the Jim Rome
Show.
The bigger news occurred the next day. Tuesday turned
out to be the final live airing of The Ultimate Sports
Show, with Kenny Stabler,
Chris Stewart and Mike Grace. The crew apparently found
out on Wednesday that their show was canceled, because
Stewart was seen
Tuesday night booking guests for later in the week.
That was right before the Alabama-Tennessee game he
was set to call.
"Best-of" shows filled the 2-6 p.m. time slot
the remainder of the week. The Herb Winches Show will
begin airing Feb. 18 on Birmingham-based WERC-AM 960,
the flagship station of The Ultimate Sports Show. Meadows
said he'll consider airing Winches at that time, but
until then he has other plans.
Beginning Monday, Inside the Auburn Tigers, with Mark
Murphy, Jason Caldwell and Brad Law will air from 4-6
p.m. The Tim Brando Show will be back on the air for
the other two hours (2-4 p.m.).
----------
Braves TV update: Atlanta-based Peachtree (WPCH) announced
this week that its 45-game Braves TV package will be
offered to TV affiliates in the Southeast.
In the Montgomery market, that package is likely to
be made available through the local cable providers.
I was unable to contact anyone at Charter, but Knology
spokesman Richard Coats said his company is seriously
considering adding the WPCH Braves games.
"Not only that, we're considering adding the 45
games in high definition," Coats said. "Nothing's
official yet, but that package is one of several HD
packages we're looking at."
If it's a popularity contest, then Braves fans need
to contact Knology at 334-356-1000 to let their feelings
known.
----------
Super tip: In the hours following Lawrence Tynes' game-winning
kick in the NFC title game two weeks ago, I communicated
with Mike Vaccaro of the New York Post. I e-mailed him
some information about Tynes' college coach -- Troy's
Larry Blakeney -- and later he sent me the results of
some crazy research he did earlier in the NFL season.
After Eli Manning had three interceptions returned for
touchdowns against Minnesota, Vaccaro recalled a game
in 1968 when Joe Namath also had three interceptions
returned for touchdowns.
"I vaguely remembered that game, and it seemed
especially relevant, so I wrote about the coincidences
back in November," Vaccaro wrote to me in an e-mail.
"Of course, after it came out, I caught a lot of
crap from people wondering if that meant I thought the
Giants were going to the Super Bowl.
"I wish I would have saved those emails."
Namath, of course, went on to help the Jets stun heavily
favored Baltimore. Now another quarterback from a Southeastern
Conference school will be trying to pull off another
astonishing upset in the big game.
Does Vaccaro think history will repeat? Not quite.
"I think it'll be a fun game," he wrote. "Pats
win, but similar to the 38-35 game they played in Week
17."
--------------------------------------------
Joe
Buck, Troy Aikman make right calls
By Bob Riassman, NY
Daily News
As time passes, it will become much bigger than it is
today. A moment that will be replayed over and over
again.
Eli Manning-to-David-Tyree for 32 yards, digging the
Giants out of a hole and putting Big Blue in position
to put an end to that perfect season.
Perfection, stopped by a desperation scramble followed
by an unconscious catch. And in the space of seconds
on Fox last night, Joe Buck and Troy Aikman offered
the perfect caption.
On TV, precise play-by-play is not necessary. No need
to paint the word picture when there are real pictures
available to tell the story. On this play, Buck delivered
just the right words. Aikman, well, he provided the
kind of emotion only a quarterback, realizing the difficulty
of this incredible hookup, could.
Montana-to-Clark has nothing on this catch.
Third-and-5 from the Giants' 44.
Buck: "Pressure from (Adalius) Thomas off the edge.
... Eli Manning. ... Stays on his feet. Airs it out
downfield. It is caught by Tyree inside the 25."
Aikman: "Oh my God. ... Tyree goes up for it like
a basketball player. Eli Manning. I don't know how he
got out of there. He got out of the pile and just slings
it."
This was the second time Buck and Aikman had worked
a Super Bowl. Considering what was at stake, considering
the frantic finish they called, it's not an assignment
either voice will soon forget.
Fox's telecast was memorable as well. It lived up to
the moment.
This was a solid effort not encumbered by gratuitous
technolgy, statistical overkill, or vocal hyperbole.
Okay, so Buck and Aikman never brought up SpyGate. On
this night, as the story of this big game played out,
scandal would have just gotten in the way. Besides,
in the hours leading up to this matchup, the airwaves
were full of the story, which had to be a huge embarrassment
to the NFL.
The Giants provided a kind of deodorant to the SpyGate
stench. Tyree's catch, and Manning's wild scramble,
were the most sensational highlight. There were others.
Memorable shots provided by Fox's cameras fueled this
drama.
• Asante Samuel letting out a scream of agony
after nearly intercepting Manning's pass that would
have sealed the win for New England - one play before
Manning-to-Tyree.
• The blank look on Chase Blackburn's face after
being penalized for being the 12th man on the field.
• Tom Coughlin running on the field and calling
timeout during the Giants' final drive.
• Antonio Pierce gasping for air as Tom Brady
took New England on its fourth-quarter scoring drive.
•
Plaxico Burress breaking down and crying during a postgame
interview with Pam Oliver.
•
Peyton Manning clapping and fist-pumping after his brother
hit Burress for what turned out to be the winning score.
•
Bill Belichick hugging Coughlin, then running off the
field with one second still left in the game.
And those bananas.
Almost on cue, after Oliver reported the Giants were
given bananas to stop cramping (Fox showed a few bananas
lying on the Giants bench), the Patriots went on their
fourth-quarter scoring drive.
Giants defenders were out of breath. Fox had a shot
of Osi Umenyiora gasping on the sideline. Then there
was Pierce, on the field, with his mouth hanging open.
Next to feel the effects was Justin Tuck, who was shown
leaving the game. Then it was Fred Robbins laying on
the ground.
The Giants' defense was hanging on and, on third-and-goal,
Buck delivered a call reminiscent of the late, great
Ray Scott.
"Brady throws ... Moss ... Touchdown."
Buck was just as econmical in calling Burress' game-winning
score.
"Manning lobs it ... Burress alone ... Touchdown
New York."
At halftime, Howie Long set the stage for a crucial
story line. Long turned out to be right. Sort of.
"This Patriots defense has been on the field for
19 minutes and 27 seconds in the first half," Long
said. "How does that manifest itself, in terms
of fatigue in the second half and inability to rush
the quarterback? Suddenly, you start getting gashed
by the running game."
Credit Long with half the story. The Giants were clearly
gassed as well. Viewers could see it from the closeups
Fox offered. The fatigue was as much emotional as physical.
Buck and Aikman did not embellish any of this. Buck,
once again, showed how to use silence. Down the stretch,
on both the Pats' and
Giants' fourth-quarter drives, he went mute and let
the crowd in.
And when it was all over, Buck said it simply. And it
was all that was left to say.
"The Giants have won the Super Bowl."
-------------------------------------------------
Buck, Aikman get Super credit
Neil Best - Newsday
Across the continent, from Long Island to Fox's vast
compound outside University of Phoenix Stadium, what
likely will be the largest TV audience in the history
of American sports was losing its collective head.
Was
this really happening? Oh, my goodness gracious.
Inside
the Fox booth Sunday night, though, Joe Buck and Troy
Aikman managed to describe one of the greatest upsets
of all time with calm intensity that did the frantic
final minutes justice.
They resisted the temptation for sappiness, both about
the Patriots' quest for perfection and the Giants' extraordinary
accomplishment.
"The
Giants have won the Super Bowl," Buck said simply
when it was over, then let the pictures tell the story.
"Wow,"
lip-readers saw Tom Coughlin say.
Soon,
Plaxico Burress was crying after an interview with Pam
Oliver and Jeff Feagles was telling his family, "Just
take it all in, boys."
"Wow,"
host Curt Menefee said to start the postgame.
"Wow,"
added Jimmy Johnson, who with Howie Long picked the
Giants to lose all four playoff games.
The
only time Aikman expressed marvel was after the game's
most remarkable play, Eli Manning's mad scramble on
third-and-long to find David Tyree, who caught the ball
against his helmet. "Oh, my gosh," he said.
"Wow."
There's
that word again.
Buck
and Aikman could have done a better job explaining in
detail exactly how and why the Giants were able to shut
down the Patriots' record-breaking offense, especially
Randy Moss.
They
also should have been more specific about the mad shuffling
on the Giants' defensive line as their players succumbed
to fatigue during New England's go-ahead drive.
But
given the chaos around them, the two got through it
with no major mistakes or misfires.
Aikman
set up the drama of the Giants' final drive, saying:
"Every quarterback dreams of being in this position,
Super Bowl on the line, down four points, trying to
take your team down and win the game."
As
he often does, Buck stayed silent for a long time after
the Giants' go-ahead score, then focused on the Patriots'
last, desperate drive.
Buck
is less afraid to dip his toe into the X's and O's waters
than many play-by-play men, and showed why when he noted
early in the game that the middle might be open for
tight end Benjamin Watson because of all the attention
paid to Randy Moss.
Soon
thereafter, the Patriots' first score was set up when
Antonio Pierce was penalized for interfering with Watson
in the end zone.
Aikman
restated a theme from earlier this season when he expressed
frustration with Manning for taking a delay-of-game
penalty. "It's unbelievable," he said. "The
quarterback has to be able to know where the play clock
is and how much time is left."
Fox
followed with an excellent shot of Peyton Manning in
a suite twirling his finger, urging his little brother
to hurry up and call for the snap.
Coughlin
told Oliver at halftime that the Giants needed a game-changing
play on special teams, and they soon got it, but it
benefited the Pats.
As
Buck first noted, Chase Blackburn did not make it off
the field in time on a punt, and after Belichick challenged
the play, the Patriots got it back.
"Mark
this time down in your diary," Buck said with 11
minutes left in the third quarter. But another impressive
stand by the Giants' defense rendered Blackburn's gaffe
irrelevant.
When
it finally was over, Fox's Chris Myers drew the unenviable
task of interviewing Bill Belichick, somewhere deep
within the stunned stadium.
It
wasn't easy. "We're disappointed," Belichick
mumbled before walking away.
Thus
ended a TV drama that surpassed anything striking writers
could have conjured.
Fox's
setup is a model of efficiency
What
was the view of Super Bowl XLII like from Fox's sprawling
compound outside University of Phoenix Stadium?
Crowded,
with many wires, many trailers and many crab legs in
the catering tent. (Lesson learned: TV food is better
than newspaper food.)
Jerry
Steinberg, Fox's VP of field operations and a wisecracking
Bronx guy, arrived 10 days before the game to set up
a small town featuring 450 people, 11 mobile units,
three trailers, four satellite uplinks and one "American
Idol" host.
Steinberg
said Fox used twice as much time to set up three years
ago, this time focusing on efficiency over complexity.
"The simplest solutions are the most elegant; that
was our philosophy," he said. "It has been
flawless."
That
was three hours before kickoff. What if something went
wrong during the game?
"Don't
look for me," he said.
Fox's
red-carpet pregame just so-so
Fox's
four-hour pregame show had its moments, including entertaining
behind-the-scenes video shot by Michael Strahan. Not
surprisingly, the funkiest stuff was Ryan Seacrest and
his "red carpet" interviews with people who
mostly had promotional and/or advertising ties to Fox.
Tough
question for Roger Goodell, amid more twists in the
Spygate scandal: How about a prediction? "We'll
have a great game," Goodell said. "Thanks,
man, have fun," Seacrest said.
Tough
question for Steve Tisch: "I assume you're rooting
for the Giants. Said Tisch: "I am the Giants' biggest
fan today."
Seacrest
asked Laurence Fishburne about the "scrutinization"
the players are under, and Hugh Laurie about his father
winning 1948 Olympic gold in "coxless pairs"
rowing.
Producer
Scott Ackerson promised last week that Paula Abdul's
new video would not be as awful as many expected. She
did OK. She is very spry for 45.
Scary
actor Russell Crowe voiced a piece about perfection
that was cool but a little scary.